edoc-Server der Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin

SPEPS Preprint

Author(s): Pierre Girardeau, CERMICS-ENPC
Title: A comparison of sample-based stochastic optimal control methods
Date of Acceptance: 04.06.2010
Submission Date: 10.02.2010
Series Title: Stochastic Programming E-Print Series
(SPEPS)
Editors: Julie L. Higle; Werner Römisch; Surrajeet Sen
Complete Preprint: pdf (urn:nbn:de:kobv:11-100112700)
Keywords (eng): stochastic programming, stochastic optimal control, particle methods
Metadata export: To export the complete metadata set as Endote or Bibtex format please click to the appropriate link. Endnote   Bibtex  
print on demand: If you click on this icon you can order a print copy of this publication. Bestellung als gedruckte und gebundene Version bei epubli.de, Ausführung der Bestellung erst nach Bestätigung auf den epubli.de-Seiten
Diese Seite taggen: These icons lead to social bookmarking systems where you can create and manage personal bookmarks and discover bookmakrs of other users.
  • connotea
  • del.icio.us
  • Furl
  • RawSugar

Abstract (eng):
In this paper, we compare the performance of two scenario-based numerical methods to solve stochastic optimal control problems: scenario trees and particles. The problem consists in finding strategies to control a dynamical system perturbed by exogenous noises so as to minimize some expected cost along a discrete and finite time horizon. We introduce the Mean Squared Error (MSE) which is the expected $L^2$-distance between the strategy given by the algorithm and the optimal strategy, as a performance indicator for the two models. We study the behaviour of the MSE with respect to the number of scenarios used for discretization. The first model, widely studied in the Stochastic Programming community, consists in approximating the noise diffusion using a scenario tree representation. On a numerical example, we observe that the number of scenarios needed to obtain a given precision grows exponentially with the time horizon. In that sense, our conclusion on scenario trees is equivalent to the one in the work by Shapiro (2006) and has been widely noticed by practitioners. However, in the second part, we show using the same example that, by mixing Stochastic Programming and Dynamic Programming ideas, the particle method described by Carpentier et al. (2009) copes with this numerical difficulty: the number of scenarios needed to obtain a given precision now does not depend on the time horizon. Unfortunately, we also observe that serious obstacles still arise from the system state space dimension.
Access Statistics: These data concerning access statistics for individual documents have been compiled using the webserver log files aggregated by AWSTATS. They refer to a monthly access count to the full text documents as well as to the entry page.
 
As for format versions of a document which consist of multiple files (such as HTML) the highest monthly access number to one of the files (chapters) is shown respectivly.
 
To see the detailled access numbers please move the mouse pointer over the single bars of the digaram.
Startseite: 5 Zugriffe PDF: 4 Zugriffe Startseite: 12 Zugriffe PDF: 4 Zugriffe Startseite: 4 Zugriffe PDF: 4 Zugriffe Startseite: 1 Zugriffe PDF: 2 Zugriffe Startseite: 2 Zugriffe PDF: 4 Zugriffe Startseite: 4 Zugriffe PDF: 5 Zugriffe Startseite: 10 Zugriffe PDF: 6 Zugriffe Startseite: 4 Zugriffe PDF: 3 Zugriffe Startseite: 3 Zugriffe PDF: 5 Zugriffe Startseite: 2 Zugriffe PDF: 3 Zugriffe Startseite: 1 Zugriffe PDF: 5 Zugriffe PDF: 3 Zugriffe Startseite: 4 Zugriffe PDF: 3 Zugriffe Startseite: 1 Zugriffe PDF: 6 Zugriffe Startseite: 3 Zugriffe PDF: 5 Zugriffe PDF: 12 Zugriffe PDF: 1 Zugriffe Startseite: 2 Zugriffe PDF: 4 Zugriffe PDF: 7 Zugriffe Startseite: 1 Zugriffe PDF: 10 Zugriffe PDF: 13 Zugriffe Startseite: 4 Zugriffe PDF: 16 Zugriffe PDF: 5 Zugriffe Startseite: 1 Zugriffe PDF: 7 Zugriffe PDF: 5 Zugriffe Startseite: 2 Zugriffe PDF: 5 Zugriffe Startseite: 2 Zugriffe PDF: 6 Zugriffe Startseite: 3 Zugriffe PDF: 4 Zugriffe Startseite: 1 Zugriffe PDF: 1 Zugriffe Startseite: 1 Zugriffe PDF: 7 Zugriffe PDF: 4 Zugriffe Startseite: 2 Zugriffe PDF: 7 Zugriffe
Jul
11
Aug
11
Sep
11
Oct
11
Nov
11
Dec
11
Jan
12
Feb
12
Apr
12
May
12
Jun
12
Jul
12
Aug
12
Sep
12
Oct
12
Nov
12
Dec
12
Jan
13
Feb
13
Mar
13
Apr
13
May
13
Jun
13
Jul
13
Aug
13
Sep
13
Oct
13
Nov
13
Dec
13
Jan
14
Feb
14
Mar
14
Monat Jul
11
Aug
11
Sep
11
Oct
11
Nov
11
Dec
11
Jan
12
Feb
12
Apr
12
May
12
Jun
12
Jul
12
Aug
12
Sep
12
Oct
12
Nov
12
Dec
12
Jan
13
Feb
13
Mar
13
Apr
13
May
13
Jun
13
Jul
13
Aug
13
Sep
13
Oct
13
Nov
13
Dec
13
Jan
14
Feb
14
Mar
14
Startseite 5 12 4 1 2 4 10 4 3 2 1   4 1 3     2   1   4   1   2 2 3 1 1   2
PDF 4 4 4 2 4 5 6 3 5 3 5 3 3 6 5 12 1 4 7 10 13 16 5 7 5 5 6 4 1 7 4 7

Gesamtzahl der Zugriffe seit Jul 2011:

  • Startseite – 75 (2.34 pro Monat)
  • PDF – 176 (5.5 pro Monat)
 
 
Generated at 19.04.2014, 11:42:56